ANALYSIS
The Great Cloud Migration Debate
Why On-Premises Active Directory Still Matters
Roman Kuznetsov @ 03.09.2025
Follow Roman Kuznetsov on LinkedIn
At Systola, we've been working in IT security since 2003, witnessing firsthand how enterprise identity management has evolved. As the creators of SystoLOCK, a passwordless, multi-factor authentication solution designed for on-premises Active Directory, we've had a front-row seat to one of the biggest debates in enterprise IT: the future of identity in a cloud-first world.

Microsoft has made its position clear. The company continues to push a cloud-first agenda, encouraging organizations to abandon their on-premises foundations and embrace Entra ID (formerly Azure AD) as the future. But when you look closely at how enterprises are actually moving, the story is far more complex.
Microsoft's Cloud-First Agenda
vs. Enterprise Reality
Microsoft's guidance frames cloud migration as a mandatory, multi-year journey. Recent moves, such as retiring Azure Multi-Factor Authentication Server in September 2024 and rolling out Entra-exclusive features, reinforce this direction.

Yet adoption rates tell a different story. Only 17% of enterprises have transitioned fully to the cloud. By contrast, 73% are running hybrid models, balancing on-premises infrastructure with cloud capabilities.
This isn't reluctance or conservatism, it's pragmatism. Enterprises are navigating a maze of regulatory requirements, legacy systems, and financial realities that make a "cloud-only" future less feasible than Microsoft suggests.
Why On-Premises Isn't Going Away
For large organizations, the persistence of on-premises systems is not about nostalgia. It's about dealing with real-world constraints that cloud migration cannot yet overcome.

Regulatory and compliance obligations are one major factor. Nearly two-thirds of organizations face compliance challenges when moving to the cloud, often resulting in significant delays. Industries like finance, healthcare, and government face strict data sovereignty mandates that require sensitive information to remain within organizational boundaries. Regulations such as GDPR and HIPAA are not optional, they're non-negotiable.

Technical and financial barriers compound the challenge. Despite Microsoft's advances, Entra ID still lacks certain core capabilities found in classic Active Directory. A simple lift-and-shift is impossible for many enterprises. Legacy applications may need years, sometimes up to a decade, to be fully cloud-ready. In many cases, migration would demand expensive middleware or complete system redesign.
Even though some analyses suggest cloud identity can be cheaper over the long term, enterprises often stick with hybrid deployments. The reason is clear: functional requirements and risk management outweigh potential savings.
Hybrid Is the New Standard
The result of these pressures is not hesitation, but a new equilibrium. Hybrid identity has emerged as the enterprise standard, and it is not a temporary way station.

More than half of businesses already operate hybrid Microsoft environments. On average, enterprises juggle between 2 and 3 public and private clouds, and 90% of large organizations rely on multi-cloud infrastructures. These aren't transitional models, they're deliberate, strategic choices designed to maximize flexibility and resilience.

Hybrid is not the middle ground. It's the destination.
Where SystoLOCK Fits
SystoLOCK was designed from the ground up for this hybrid reality. At its core, it eliminates passwords entirely, replacing them with phishing-resistant authentication based on cryptographic keys and digital certificates. This approach strengthens security without disrupting existing on-premises Active Directory foundations.

At the same time, SystoLOCK integrates seamlessly with most cloud services. Enterprises gain the freedom to adopt cloud innovations while maintaining on-premises control over sensitive identity data. The result is a compliance-friendly solution that bridges both worlds.
The Road Ahead for Enterprise Identity
Looking forward, we see three distinct phases of enterprise identity management:

  • Short term (1-2 years): Enterprises will double down on strengthening on-premises security while building hybrid integration. This means deploying phishing-resistant authentication like SystoLOCK to meet today's compliance and security demands.

  • Medium term (2-5 years): Expect hybrid dominance. Core authentication will remain on-premises, but cloud will take on supporting roles in management, analytics, and monitoring. This balances Microsoft's cloud-first direction with enterprise control needs.

  • Long term (5+ years): Identity-as-a-service models will emerge, running in containerized environments across on-premises, private, and public clouds. AI will play a greater role in easing migrations and managing identity risks.
Market Momentum
The numbers confirm what enterprises already know. The global identity and access management (IAM) market is projected to grow from $17.2 billion in 2025 to $73.3 billion by 2035, with hybrid deployments and compliance requirements driving much of that growth.

Meanwhile, the passwordless authentication market is experiencing explosive expansion, expected to reach nearly $119 billion by 2032. This validates our approach with SystoLOCK: passwordless is the future, but cloud-only is not the requirement.
Conclusion: Moving Beyond Either/Or
Microsoft's push for the cloud is strong, but enterprise reality is more nuanced. The future isn't about choosing between on-premises and cloud, it's about leveraging the strengths of both.

That's why we built SystoLOCK. It delivers enterprise-grade, passwordless authentication for on-premises Active Directory while ensuring compatibility with cloud services. For organizations that must balance compliance, risk, and innovation, hybrid is not a compromise. It's the smart, strategic path forward.

👉 Want to see this in action? Request a demo and discover how SystoLOCK can strengthen your hybrid Active Directory environment with passwordless authentication.